Comparing Group Health Insurance vs Individual Policies

As FCA-authorised experts in UK motor insurance at WeCovr, we have helped over 800,000 clients protect their business assets on the road. We understand that comprehensive protection goes beyond vehicles. This guide explores another vital asset—your people—by comparing group health insurance with individual policies for your business.

Which is cheaper — and better — for your business

Deciding between group health insurance and funding individual policies for your staff is a significant financial and strategic decision. For the vast majority of UK businesses, Group Health Insurance is both cheaper per person and better for the organisation overall.

Group schemes spread the insurance risk across all members, which drives down the cost of premiums compared to individual policies. Crucially, they also deliver powerful benefits for company culture, employee retention, and productivity that individual plans simply cannot match.

While the group option is typically superior, the "better" choice ultimately hinges on your specific business size, budget, and long-term strategic goals. This guide will break down all the key differences to help you make a truly informed decision for your company's future.

Understanding the Fundamentals: What is Business Health Insurance?

Before we dive into a detailed comparison, let's clarify what we mean by these two options. Both are designed to provide your team with access to private medical treatment, helping them to bypass lengthy NHS waiting lists for eligible conditions and get back to health, and work, sooner.

What is Group Health Insurance?

Often called a company health scheme or corporate private medical insurance (PMI), this is a single policy taken out by a business to cover a group of people—its employees. The company pays the premium directly to the insurer, creating a highly valued employee benefit. Some schemes can be set up to allow for employee contributions if desired.

Key characteristics include:

• One Master Policy: The business is the policyholder and manages the relationship with the insurer.
• Risk Pooling: The insurer calculates the premium based on the collective risk profile of the entire group, not the health of one individual.
• Uniform Coverage: All employees within a defined group or tier receive the same level of benefits, ensuring fairness and clarity.

What is an Individual Private Medical Insurance (PMI) Policy?

This is a health insurance policy that an individual takes out and owns themselves, designed to cover their own medical needs and, optionally, those of their family.

In a business context, an employer might choose to offer employees a cash allowance as part of their salary. The employee then uses this money to find and purchase their own individual PMI policy.

Key characteristics include:

• Personal Contract: The contract is between the employee and the insurer. The business has no involvement beyond providing the cash allowance.
• Individual Underwriting: The premium is calculated based entirely on that one person's circumstances: their age, medical history, lifestyle choices (like smoking), and postcode.
• Flexible but Fragmented: The employee has total freedom to choose their insurer and level of cover. For the business, this creates a fragmented, inconsistent, and administratively heavy approach.

Group Health Insurance vs Individual Policies: A Head-to-Head Comparison

To make the choice clearer, let's compare the two options across the factors that matter most to a business owner or manager.

Real-Life Example: A 20-employee engineering firm in Derby wants to offer health cover to boost retention.

• Group Scheme Path: They receive a quote for a comprehensive group policy at £50 per employee per month (£1,000 total). The scheme's "moratorium" underwriting means that pre-existing conditions can be covered after a two-year symptom-free period. Administration is a single monthly payment.
• Individual Policy Path: The firm offers a £50/month allowance.
  • A 25-year-old non-smoker finds a basic policy for £42/month.
  • A 48-year-old manager with a history of knee problems is quoted £125/month for equivalent cover, with a permanent exclusion for anything related to his knees.
  • The total cost is unpredictable, the administration is a payroll nightmare, and the cover is unequal and inadequate for senior staff.

The Group Scheme is the clear winner for cost, fairness, and simplicity.

The Cost Question: Is Group Health Insurance Really Cheaper?

For any business with two or more employees, the answer is a resounding yes. The core reason for this is a powerful insurance principle called "risk pooling".

How Risk Pooling Works: Think about how we assess risk for fleet insurance. If you insure a single delivery van, the insurer's risk is concentrated on that one vehicle and driver. If you insure a fleet of 50 vans, the insurer knows that while one or two vans might have an accident in a year, it's statistically very unlikely that all 50 will. The risk is spread out, so the price per van is lower.

Group health insurance applies the exact same logic to people. The insurer assesses the collective risk of your entire team. The presence of younger, healthier employees who are less likely to claim naturally balances the higher risk presented by older employees or those with past health issues. This creates a stable, predictable, and much lower average premium per person.

According to the Association of British Insurers (ABI), the cost of individual private medical insurance can fluctuate dramatically based on age and health, whereas group schemes provide a much more stable and budget-friendly cost structure for businesses.

Factors That Influence the Cost of Group Health Insurance

Just like your motor policy, the final price of a group health scheme depends on several factors. Understanding these allows you to tailor a plan to your budget.

1. Average Age of Employees: A younger workforce will generally result in a lower starting premium.
2. Company Size: The more employees you add to the scheme, the more effectively the risk is pooled. This gives you greater negotiating power and often leads to lower per-person costs.
3. Level of Cover: You can choose the level of protection, much like with motor insurance. A basic plan might only cover in-patient treatment (when you need a hospital bed), while a comprehensive plan could add out-patient consultations, diagnostics, dental, and optical benefits.
4. Underwriting Method: This is a key factor. The main types are:
   • Full Medical Underwriting: Cheaper, but employees must declare their full medical history.
   • Moratorium: The most common type. Pre-existing conditions from the last 5 years are excluded, but can be automatically included after a 2-year clear period.
   • Medical History Disregarded (MHD): The gold standard, available to larger groups. It covers all eligible conditions, including pre-existing ones. It is the most expensive but offers complete peace of mind.
5. Industry & Location: A business with office-based staff in a low-risk industry will likely pay less than a construction company, which has higher physical risks. Your business location also matters, as private hospital costs vary across the UK.
6. Excess Level: The excess is the amount an employee pays towards the cost of a claim, identical to the excess on your car insurance. Choosing a higher excess (e.g., £250 or £500 per claim) will significantly lower the overall premium your business pays.

A Motor Insurance Perspective: Managing Risk Across Your Business

As experts in motor insurance UK, we advise our clients to take a comprehensive view of business risk. Protecting your vehicles with the right insurance is a legal and commercial imperative. Protecting your people with health insurance is a strategic one. Both are fundamental to business continuity and success.

Your Legal Duty: Compulsory Motor Insurance

In the United Kingdom, no business that uses vehicles can afford to neglect its legal insurance duties. The Road Traffic Act 1988 is unequivocal: every vehicle on a public road must be insured to at least a third-party level.

• Third-Party Only (TPO): This is the absolute legal minimum. It covers injury to other people (the "third party") or damage to their property that you cause. It crucially does not cover any damage to your own vehicle or driver.
• Third-Party, Fire and Theft (TPFT): This includes all TPO cover, plus it protects your own vehicle if it is damaged by fire or stolen.
• Comprehensive: This is the highest level of vehicle cover. It includes everything in TPFT but also pays for repairs to your own vehicle, even if an accident was your fault. It typically includes extras like windscreen cover as standard.

For a business, this legal duty extends to ensuring you have the correct business car insurance for employees using their personal cars for work-related travel (beyond commuting), and robust fleet insurance for companies operating two or more vehicles. Getting this wrong isn't just a financial gamble; it's a violation of the law.

Protecting Your Fleet, Protecting Your People

A successful business owner thinks of their organisation as having two critical fleets: your fleet of vehicles that drives revenue, and your 'fleet' of people that drives innovation and service. Both require protection.

Managing both fleets with the same diligent, risk-averse approach is a hallmark of a resilient and well-run organisation.

Understanding Key Insurance Concepts: NCB, Excess, and Optional Extras

The world of insurance has its own language, but the core concepts are often universal. Understanding these terms will help you find the best car insurance provider and the best health provider.

• No-Claims Bonus (NCB) / No-Claims Discount (NCD): In car insurance, you earn a significant discount for every year you drive without making a claim. In group health insurance, a similar principle applies. If your group has a low claims history, your insurer is likely to offer a more favourable premium at renewal, rewarding your company's collective good health.
• Excess: This is the fixed amount you (or your employee) agree to pay towards any claim. With a motor policy, you pay this to the garage when your car is repaired. With a health policy, the employee pays this towards their treatment cost. In both scenarios, volunteering for a higher excess will lower your premium.
• Optional Extras: You can enhance your core insurance policy with valuable add-ons.
  • Motor Insurance: Common extras include breakdown cover, legal expenses cover (to pursue uninsured losses), and a guaranteed courtesy car.
  • Group Health Insurance: Popular additions include dental and optical cover, mental health support pathways, and worldwide travel insurance.

At WeCovr, we help you navigate these options for all your insurance needs. We ensure you're not paying for extras you don't need and can also secure discounts on other types of cover when you purchase motor or life insurance through us.

Beyond Cost: The Strategic Advantages of Group Health Insurance

While group health cover is cheaper, its true value is revealed in the powerful strategic benefits it delivers to your business.

1. Attracting and Retaining Top Talent: In today's competitive job market, salary is not the only factor. A comprehensive benefits package is a key differentiator, and private health insurance consistently ranks as one of the most desired employee benefits.
2. Reducing Sickness Absence: NHS waiting lists for certain procedures can stretch for many months. This can mean a key employee is off sick, unable to work, for a prolonged period. Private medical insurance provides swift access to diagnosis and treatment, dramatically cutting the length of sickness absence and its associated costs (sick pay, hiring temporary staff, lost productivity).
3. Boosting Productivity and Morale: An employee who feels their employer genuinely cares about their well-being is more likely to be engaged, motivated, and loyal. Providing a health safety net reduces stress and financial anxiety, allowing your team to focus on their work. Our high customer satisfaction ratings are built on finding policies that add real, tangible value to businesses.
4. Creating a Proactive Health Culture: A modern group health scheme is more than just reactive treatment. Many providers include proactive wellness services like 24/7 digital GP access, mental health support apps, discounted gym memberships, and health screening services, helping you build a healthier, more resilient workforce.

Making the Right Choice for Your Business with WeCovr

The best choice depends on your company's scale and ambition.

• For small businesses or start-ups (2-5 employees): A group health scheme is the ideal choice. It is more cost-effective than individual policies, far simpler to administer, and sets a fantastic precedent for company culture as you grow.
• For SMEs (5-250 employees): Group health insurance is unquestionably the cheaper, better, and more strategic option. The benefits of risk pooling, administrative simplicity, and its power as a retention tool are immense.
• For large corporations (250+ employees): Group health insurance is an expected standard. The conversation here shifts to optimising the scheme with flexible benefit tiers, incorporating healthcare trusts, and integrating the plan into a wider corporate wellness and ESG strategy.

As an FCA-authorised expert broker, WeCovr specialises in helping UK businesses compare their options transparently. We don't just find the cheapest price; we find the best-fit policy for your unique needs, whether that's a single van policy, comprehensive fleet insurance, or helping you understand your options for business health cover.

Ready to protect your business from every angle? Whether you need to insure your vehicles or explore benefits for your team, WeCovr provides expert, no-cost advice to find the perfect cover.

[Get Your Free Motor Insurance Quote from WeCovr Today]