Deciding how to protect your family’s financial future is one of the most important decisions a couple can make. As you build a life together, taking on a mortgage, raising children, or starting a business, you create shared financial responsibilities. Life insurance is the bedrock of a solid financial plan, acting as a safety net if the worst should happen.
For couples in the UK, a key question arises: is it better to buy two separate single life insurance policies, or one joint policy?
The answer isn't always straightforward. While a joint policy might seem simpler and cheaper on the surface, it has significant drawbacks that could leave your family under-protected. This comprehensive 2025 guide will walk you through the pros and cons of each option, explore different types of cover, and provide the expert insights you need to make the right choice for your unique circumstances.
Pros and cons of joint vs single life policies for couples
At its core, the choice between joint and single life insurance is a balance between cost, coverage, and flexibility. Understanding the fundamental differences is the first step towards making an informed decision.
A joint life insurance policy covers two people but only pays out once. Most commonly, this is on a 'first death' basis, meaning the policy pays the lump sum when the first partner dies, and then the policy ends. This leaves the surviving partner without any life cover.
Two single life insurance policies mean each partner has their own individual cover. If one partner dies, their policy pays out, and the surviving partner’s policy remains active. If both partners were to die, both policies would pay out, providing a significantly larger sum for dependants.
Let's break down the advantages and disadvantages of each approach in a clear, side-by-side comparison.
| Feature | Joint Life Insurance | Two Single Life Policies |
|---|
| Premiums | Generally cheaper than two single policies. | Usually more expensive than one joint policy. |
| Payout | Pays out only once, on the first death. | Each policy pays out independently. Potential for two payouts. |
| Coverage After Claim | The policy ends after a claim is paid. | The surviving partner's policy remains in force. |
| Flexibility | Inflexible. Difficult to manage upon separation or divorce. | Highly flexible. Policies are independent of the relationship. |
| Customisation | Both individuals are covered for the same amount. | Each policy can be tailored to the individual's needs (cover, term). |
| Best For | Couples on a tight budget with a specific liability like a mortgage. | Couples with children, complex finances, or who want maximum protection. |
Now, let's dive deeper into what these points mean for you and your family.
The Case for Joint Life Insurance: Simplicity and Cost
The primary appeal of a joint life policy is its cost-effectiveness.
- Lower Premiums: Because the insurer only has to pay out once, the risk is lower for them, and this saving is passed on to you. A joint policy is often 10-25% cheaper than two equivalent single policies.
- Simplicity: One application, one monthly direct debit, one set of documents. For busy couples, this administrative ease can be attractive. It feels like a "couples' product" for a "couples' debt" like a mortgage.
However, this simplicity comes at a price – a lack of flexibility and reduced overall protection.
The Drawbacks of Joint Life Insurance: A Single Safety Net
The single payout structure is the most significant disadvantage.
- One Payout Only: Once the policy pays out on the first death, the cover ceases. The surviving partner is then left with no life insurance. They would need to apply for a new policy at an older age, likely with higher premiums, and potentially with new health conditions that could make cover very expensive or even unobtainable.
- Relationship Breakdown: What happens if you separate or divorce? This is where joint policies can become a real headache. You cannot simply split the policy in two. The options are usually to cancel it (leaving both of you uninsured) or have one person take over the payments, which can be complicated and contentious. Some modern policies now offer a 'separation option', but it's not a standard feature.
- One-Size-Fits-All Cover: A joint policy covers both partners for the same amount. But what if one partner earns significantly more or has different needs? You might be over-insuring one partner and under-insuring the other.
What is Joint Life Insurance and How Does It Work?
To make the right choice, it's crucial to understand the mechanics of the products available. A joint life policy is a single contract of insurance taken out on the lives of two people, typically a married couple, civil partners, or cohabiting partners.
There are two main types of joint life insurance policies:
1. First Death (or 'First-to-Die') Policies
This is by far the most common type of joint life insurance sold in the UK.
- How it works: The policy pays out the pre-agreed cash lump sum upon the death of the first person insured.
- The key feature: Once the claim is paid, the policy terminates. The surviving partner receives the money but no longer has any life cover under that policy.
- Primary Use: Its main purpose is to cover a large joint debt, most commonly a repayment mortgage. The logic is that if one partner dies, the payout is sufficient to clear the mortgage, relieving the financial burden on the survivor.
Example: Sarah and Tom have a £300,000 mortgage. They take out a £300,000 joint life 'first death' policy. If Tom were to die, the policy would pay £300,000 to Sarah, which she could use to pay off the mortgage. The policy then ends, and Sarah has no further life cover from it.
2. Second Death (or 'Last Survivor') Policies
This type of policy is less common and serves a very different, more specialist purpose.
- How it works: The policy only pays out upon the death of the second person insured.
- The key feature: No payment is made when the first partner dies. The surviving partner must continue to pay the premiums until they pass away, at which point the lump sum is paid to their estate or beneficiaries.
- Primary Use: Its main purpose is for Inheritance Tax (IHT) planning. Married couples and civil partners can pass assets to each other tax-free. IHT is typically only due on the second death. A 'second death' policy, when written in trust, can provide the funds to pay the resulting IHT bill, preventing beneficiaries from having to sell family assets (like the home) to cover the tax.
What are Single Life Insurance Policies?
The alternative is for each partner to take out their own, separate life insurance policy. This creates two independent contracts with the insurer.
- How it works: Each partner has a policy in their own name. They can choose their own level of cover and policy term. Often, couples will take out policies that mirror each other.
- The key feature: If one partner dies, their policy pays out to their nominated beneficiary (usually the surviving partner). The surviving partner's own policy remains completely unaffected and continues as long as they pay the premiums.
- Primary Use: This provides a far more comprehensive safety net. It can be used not just to clear a mortgage, but also to provide a lump sum for the surviving partner to live on, and to leave an inheritance for children. In the tragic event of both partners dying (e.g., in a car accident), both policies would pay out, leaving a substantial legacy for their children or other dependants.
Example: Sarah and Tom each take out a £300,000 single life policy. If Tom were to die, his policy pays £300,000 to Sarah. She can use this to clear the mortgage. Crucially, Sarah’s own £300,000 policy is still active. She can continue it, providing a future inheritance for their children. If they were to die together, their children would inherit £600,000.
Joint vs. Single Policies: A Head-to-Head Cost Comparison
While we've established that two single policies are generally more expensive, the difference is often smaller than people think. The peace of mind and flexibility offered by single policies can be well worth the modest extra cost.
Let's look at some illustrative examples. These are based on quotes for non-smoking individuals in good health seeking level term assurance (the payout amount stays the same throughout the term).
Scenario 1: Young Couple with a Mortgage
- Couple: David and Emily, both 32, non-smokers, good health.
- Cover Needed: £250,000 over a 25-year term to cover their mortgage.
| Policy Type | Illustrative Monthly Premium | Total Potential Payout |
|---|
| Joint 'First Death' Policy | £18.50 | £250,000 |
| Two Single Policies (£250k each) | £21.00 (£10.50 each) | £500,000 |
In this scenario, for just £2.50 extra per month, David and Emily can double their family's potential payout and ensure the survivor retains their own valuable cover. For the price of a single cup of coffee, they gain immense extra protection.
Scenario 2: Couple in their 40s with a Smoker
- Couple: Mark, 45 (non-smoker), and Lisa, 43 (smoker).
- Cover Needed: £150,000 decreasing term assurance over 20 years.
| Policy Type | Illustrative Monthly Premium |
|---|
| Joint 'First Death' Policy | £25.00 |
| Two Single Policies | £28.00 (Mark: £9.50, Lisa: £18.50) |
Here, the joint policy's premium is based on the higher risk presented by Lisa, the smoker. By taking out single policies, Mark benefits from his non-smoker status with a very low premium, while Lisa's premium reflects her individual risk. The overall difference is still minimal, and it gives them the flexibility to manage their policies separately.
These examples highlight why it's crucial not to default to the 'cheaper' joint option without doing the maths. At WeCovr, our expert advisors can run these comparisons for you in minutes, showing you precise quotes from across the UK's leading insurance providers, ensuring you see the full picture.
Key Factors to Consider When Making Your Decision
The right choice is deeply personal. Sit down with your partner and work through these key questions to determine the best path for your family.
-
What is Your Primary Goal?
- Is it solely to pay off the mortgage? A joint 'first death' decreasing term policy is specifically designed for this and can be the most budget-friendly option.
- Is it to provide for your children and replace a lost income? If so, the potential for a double payout from two single policies is a powerful argument. This ensures that even after the first death, there is still a policy in place to provide a legacy for the children.
-
What Can You Realistically Afford?
- Budget is always a factor. Run the quotes for both options. If the extra cost of two single policies would strain your finances, then a well-structured joint policy is infinitely better than no policy at all. The key is to get the most comprehensive cover you can comfortably afford.
-
How Secure is Your Relationship?
- This can be an uncomfortable question, but it's a practical one. Statistics from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show that a significant percentage of marriages end in divorce. For cohabiting couples, the rate of separation is higher.
- A joint policy is tied to the relationship. Two single policies are tied to the individuals. If you separate, you can each take your policy with you, with no fuss and no need to re-apply for cover when you are older.
-
Do You Have Different Health Profiles or Lifestyles?
- As seen in our example, if one partner is a smoker or has a pre-existing medical condition, a joint policy premium will be "rated" (increased) based on the higher-risk individual.
- In this situation, it can be more cost-effective to get two single policies. The healthier partner will secure a standard (and cheaper) rate, while the other partner's policy will be individually underwritten.
-
Do You Need Different Levels of Cover?
- Perhaps one partner is the primary earner, and their death would have a far greater financial impact. Or maybe one partner has a "death in service" benefit from their employer, meaning they need less personal cover.
- Single policies allow you to tailor the sum assured for each person. For example, the higher earner might take a £500,000 policy, while the other partner takes a £200,000 policy. This level of customisation is impossible with a joint policy.
The Importance of Writing Your Policy 'In Trust'
Whether you choose a joint or single policy, one of the most crucial steps you can take is to write it 'in trust'. It’s a simple piece of legal paperwork, usually offered for free by the insurer, that has profound benefits.
What is a trust? A trust is a legal arrangement that separates the ownership of the life insurance policy from the payout. You (the settlor) place your policy into the trust and appoint trustees (people you trust, often family members or a solicitor) to manage it. You also name the beneficiaries (the people you want the money to go to, like your partner and children).
Why is this so important?
- It Avoids Probate: When a policy is in a trust, the payout goes directly to the trustees to be distributed to the beneficiaries. It does not form part of your legal estate. This means the money can be paid out in a matter of weeks, rather than getting stuck in the lengthy and costly probate process which can take many months, or even years. Your family gets the money when they need it most.
- It Can Avoid Inheritance Tax (IHT): Because the policy payout is not part of your estate, it is not normally subject to the 40% Inheritance Tax. For a £300,000 policy, this could be a tax saving of £120,000. This is especially vital for unmarried couples, who do not have the spouse exemption for IHT.
- You Control the Destination: The trust deed specifies exactly who you want to receive the money. This ensures your wishes are carried out and can protect the money from being used to pay off outstanding debts of the estate.
Writing a policy in trust is a simple process that an expert advisor can guide you through. It’s one of the smartest and simplest financial planning moves you can make.
Beyond Life Insurance: A Holistic Approach to Protection
Life insurance is vital, but it only covers one eventuality: death. A truly robust financial safety net protects you and your family against other risks, such as serious illness and the inability to work.
Critical Illness Cover (CIC)
This is one of the most valuable additions you can make to a life insurance policy.
- What it is: CIC pays out a tax-free lump sum if you are diagnosed with one of a list of specified serious medical conditions, such as some types of cancer, heart attack, or stroke.
- Why it's important: The financial impact of a serious illness can be devastating. You or your partner may need to stop working, you might need to make modifications to your home, or pay for private medical care. The CIC payout gives you the financial breathing room to focus on your recovery without worrying about bills.
- Joint vs. Single CIC: This is where the argument for single policies becomes even stronger. On a joint life and critical illness policy, a claim for a critical illness will pay out once, and then the entire policy often ends. This leaves both the ill person and the healthy partner without any further life or critical illness cover. With two separate policies, a claim on one has no impact on the other.
Income Protection Insurance
Often described by financial experts as the foundation of any protection plan, income protection is arguably more important than life insurance for most working people.
- What it is: If you are unable to work due to any illness or injury (not just the 'critical' ones), an income protection policy pays you a regular, tax-free monthly income until you can return to work, retire, or the policy term ends.
- Why it's essential: Your ability to earn an income is your most valuable asset. State benefits are minimal (Statutory Sick Pay is just £116.75 per week as of 2024/25). An income protection policy replaces a significant portion of your lost salary, allowing you to continue paying your mortgage, bills, and living expenses.
Family Income Benefit
This is a type of life insurance that works slightly differently from a standard lump-sum policy.
- What it is: Instead of paying out a large single sum on death, it pays out a smaller, regular, tax-free income to your family. This income is paid from the date of the claim until the end of the policy's original term.
- Why it can be a great option: It can be easier for a grieving family to manage a regular income rather than a huge lump sum. It's also often more affordable than a comparable lump-sum policy, making it a great way to protect your children's upbringing on a budget.
Special Considerations for Business Owners and the Self-Employed
If you run your own business or work for yourself, the need for a robust protection plan is even more acute. You don't have an employer's safety net to fall back on.
For the Self-Employed and Freelancers
The lack of sick pay, death-in-service benefits, or employer pension contributions means the buck stops with you.
- Income Protection is Non-Negotiable: This should be your number one priority. It's your replacement salary if you can't work. Some insurers offer policies specifically for the self-employed, with flexible definitions of incapacity that suit modern ways of working.
- Life and Critical Illness Cover: This is crucial for protecting your family and any business loans or liabilities you may have. Two single policies are almost always the superior choice, giving you maximum flexibility.
For Company Directors
As a director of your own limited company, you have access to some highly tax-efficient methods of arranging protection.
- Relevant Life Insurance: This is a way for your company to pay for your personal life insurance policy. The premiums are typically an allowable business expense, so you save on Corporation Tax. It's not treated as a 'benefit in kind', so there's no extra income tax or National Insurance to pay. The benefit is paid tax-free to your family via a trust. It’s a huge tax-saving compared to paying for a personal policy out of your post-tax income.
- Executive Income Protection: Similar to the above, this allows your company to pay for your personal income protection policy. Again, the premiums are a tax-deductible business expense, making it a far more efficient way to secure this vital cover.
- Key Person Insurance: This is different. It protects the business itself, not your family. It's a policy taken out on the life or health of a key individual whose loss would have a major financial impact on the company. The payout goes to the business to cover lost profits, recruit a replacement, or clear debts.
Navigating these business protection options requires specialist advice, something we at WeCovr are highly experienced in providing.
The WeCovr Approach: Holistic Protection and Wellness
Choosing the right insurance is a complex decision, with long-term consequences for your loved ones. It's not about finding the cheapest premium online; it's about getting the right advice to build a plan that truly protects your family.
At WeCovr, we help you navigate the complexities of joint vs. single policies, critical illness cover, and income protection. Our expert advisors take the time to understand your personal and financial situation, comparing policies and quotes from all the UK's leading insurers to find the perfect fit for your needs and budget. We're here to demystify the jargon and empower you to make confident choices.
We also believe in supporting our clients' long-term health. Proactive wellbeing is the best protection of all. That's why all our valued protection clients receive complimentary access to CalorieHero, our exclusive AI-powered calorie and nutrition tracking app. Taking small, consistent steps to improve your health today can have a big impact on your future wellbeing, and may even help you secure lower insurance premiums down the line. It's just one of the ways we go above and beyond for our clients.
Final Thoughts: Which Path Should You Choose?
So, after exploring all the angles, what's the verdict on joint vs. single life insurance for 2025?
While a joint policy can be a viable, budget-friendly solution for a couple whose sole aim is to cover a joint mortgage, in almost every other scenario, two separate single policies offer superior protection, flexibility, and long-term value.
The relatively small extra monthly cost buys you:
- The potential for two payouts, providing a far larger safety net for your children.
- The guarantee that the surviving partner remains insured after the first death.
- The flexibility to manage the policies independently if your relationship ends.
- The ability to customise the cover amount and term for each individual.
The decision is yours, but it should be an informed one. Don't simply default to the joint option because it seems cheaper or simpler. Consider your family's future, the "what ifs," and the long-term picture. Investing a few extra pounds a month today could make a world of difference to your family's security tomorrow.
Is joint life insurance always cheaper than two single policies?
Generally, a joint 'first death' policy is cheaper than two separate single policies because the insurer's risk is lower – they only have to pay out once. However, the saving is often smaller than people expect, sometimes only 10-20%. When you factor in the reduced cover and lack of flexibility, two single policies often represent better overall value for a small extra cost.
Can we have different cover amounts on a joint life policy?
No. A standard joint life insurance policy has one single sum assured that applies to both lives. If you and your partner need different levels of cover (for example, if one earns significantly more than the other), you would need to take out two single policies. This allows you to tailor each policy's sum assured to the individual's specific needs.
What happens to a joint life policy if we split up?
This is a major drawback of joint policies. You cannot simply split the policy. Your options are usually: 1) Cancel the policy, leaving both of you without cover. 2) One person agrees to take over the full premium payments, with the other person being the beneficiary (this can be complex and requires trust). 3) Continue paying it jointly to protect shared interests like children. Some modern policies include a 'separation option' which allows you to split the cover into two single policies without new medical checks, but this is not standard.
Can we change our joint policy to two single policies later?
Generally, no. You would have to cancel the joint policy and apply for two new single policies from scratch. This would involve full new medical underwriting. As you will be older, and may have developed new health conditions, the new policies would almost certainly be more expensive. This is why choosing the right structure from the start is so important.
I'm a smoker but my partner isn't. Should we get a joint policy?
In this situation, it is highly recommended to get quotes for two single policies. A joint policy's premium will be calculated based on the higher risk, meaning the smoker's status will significantly increase the overall cost. By getting two single policies, the non-smoker will secure a much cheaper premium based on their own health, and while the smoker's policy will be more expensive, the combined total of two single policies can sometimes be very close to, or even cheaper than, the joint policy.
Can unmarried couples get joint life insurance?
Yes, absolutely. To take out insurance on someone's life, you need to have an 'insurable interest', which means you would suffer a financial loss if they were to die. Cohabiting couples with a joint mortgage, shared financial commitments, or children clearly have this insurable interest and can take out joint or single policies just like married couples. It is especially important for unmarried couples to write their policies in trust to avoid potential Inheritance Tax issues.