TL;DR
Deciding on private medical insurance in the UK can feel complex, and for couples, there's an added layer: should you get a joint policy or two separate ones? As experienced brokers who have helped arrange over 900,000 policies, the team at WeCovr knows this is one of the most common questions we hear. This guide provides the definitive answer, breaking down the pros, cons, and costs of each approach.
Key takeaways
- A joint policy combines both partners under one plan, with one premium and one renewal date. It often comes with a small discount (typically 5%) and simplifies administration.
- Two separate policies mean each partner has their own individual plan. This can offer greater flexibility, protect individual No Claims Discounts, and sometimes be surprisingly cheaper, especially if there's a significant age or health difference between you.
- Age: This is the most significant factor. As we get older, the statistical likelihood of needing medical treatment increases, so premiums rise. On a joint policy, the age of both partners is considered, with the older partner typically having a greater impact on the price.
- Location: Your postcode matters. Medical treatment costs vary across the UK, with Central London hospitals being the most expensive. Insurers use your address to determine the likely cost of care in your area.
- Level of Cover: You build your policy by choosing from different components:
Deciding on private medical insurance in the UK can feel complex, and for couples, there's an added layer: should you get a joint policy or two separate ones? As experienced brokers who have helped arrange over 900,000 policies, the team at WeCovr knows this is one of the most common questions we hear. This guide provides the definitive answer, breaking down the pros, cons, and costs of each approach.
When couples private health insurance makes sense, how pricing works, and common cover structures
Navigating the world of Private Medical Insurance (PMI) as a couple presents a key decision point: combine your cover under a single joint policy or maintain two separate policies. There isn't a one-size-fits-all answer. The right choice depends entirely on your individual ages, health histories, desired cover levels, and budget.
- A joint policy combines both partners under one plan, with one premium and one renewal date. It often comes with a small discount (typically 5%) and simplifies administration.
- Two separate policies mean each partner has their own individual plan. This can offer greater flexibility, protect individual No Claims Discounts, and sometimes be surprisingly cheaper, especially if there's a significant age or health difference between you.
The core purpose of any private health insurance UK policy remains the same: to cover the costs of diagnosis and treatment for acute medical conditions that arise after your policy begins. It provides faster access to specialist consultations, diagnostic tests, and private hospital treatment, bypassing potentially long NHS waiting lists.
Crucial Point: Standard UK PMI does not cover pre-existing conditions from the outset. It also does not cover the routine management of long-term, incurable chronic conditions like diabetes, asthma, or hypertension.
This article will dissect the differences between joint and separate cover, explore how insurers calculate your premiums, and walk you through real-world scenarios to help you make the most informed decision.
Joint vs Separate Policies: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Understanding the subtle but significant differences between these two structures is the key to finding the best value. While a joint policy seems simpler, the long-term implications, especially regarding claims, can make separate policies a smarter financial choice.
Here is a detailed breakdown of the key factors:
| Feature | Joint Policy | Separate Policies | WeCovr Adviser's Insight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing & Discount | Often includes a "multi-person" discount, typically around 5%. One combined premium. | No multi-person discount. Two separate premiums. | Don't assume joint is cheaper. If one partner is older or has a less favourable medical history, their higher risk can inflate the joint premium so much that two separate policies are actually less expensive. We always quote both. |
| Administration | Simpler. One application, one set of documents, one direct debit, and one renewal date to manage. | More to manage. Two applications, two sets of documents, two payments, and two renewal dates. | The convenience of a joint policy is undeniable. However, this convenience can come at a cost if a claim is made. |
| No Claims Discount (NCD) | Shared Risk. A claim made by either person will reduce the NCD for the entire policy at renewal, increasing the premium for both. | Protected. A claim made by one person only affects their own policy and NCD. The other partner's NCD and premium remain untouched. | This is the single biggest drawback of a joint policy. A minor claim by one partner can cause a significant premium hike for both for years to come. |
| Cover Customisation | Good. Many modern insurers (like Bupa, Vitality) allow you to set different excesses or cover levels for each person. | Excellent. Total freedom to choose different insurers, cover levels, hospital lists, and underwriting for each person to perfectly match needs and budget. | If one partner wants comprehensive cover and the other only needs a basic plan, two separate policies from different specialist insurers can provide the best possible value. |
| Relationship Changes | Requires action. If the couple separates, the policy needs to be split into two individual plans, usually at renewal. | No action needed. The policies are already separate and independent of the relationship status. | Splitting a joint policy is a standard process, but it's an administrative step that separate policies avoid entirely. |
How is a Couples Health Insurance Policy Priced?
Insurers use a range of factors to calculate your premium, whether for a joint or separate policy. For a joint plan, they assess these factors for both individuals and combine them to create a single price.
-
Age: This is the most significant factor. As we get older, the statistical likelihood of needing medical treatment increases, so premiums rise. On a joint policy, the age of both partners is considered, with the older partner typically having a greater impact on the price.
-
Location: Your postcode matters. Medical treatment costs vary across the UK, with Central London hospitals being the most expensive. Insurers use your address to determine the likely cost of care in your area.
-
Level of Cover: You build your policy by choosing from different components:
- Core Cover (Essential): All policies include cover for in-patient and day-patient treatment (when you need a hospital bed).
- Out-patient Cover (Optional Add-on): This is for diagnostics and consultations that don't require a hospital bed. You can choose from full cover, a limited number of consultations, or a monetary cap (e.g., £1,000 per year). Adding this increases the premium.
- Therapies (Optional Add-on): Covers treatments like physiotherapy, osteopathy, and chiropractic care.
- Mental Health Cover (Optional Add-on): Provides access to counsellors, therapists, and psychiatrists. This is an increasingly popular and valuable addition.
- Dental & Optical (Optional Add-on): Less common, but can be added to some comprehensive plans to cover routine check-ups and treatments.
-
Excess: The excess is the amount you agree to pay towards a claim each year. For example, with a £250 excess, you pay the first £250 of your claim costs. A higher excess leads to a lower monthly premium. Couples can often choose different excess levels on a joint policy.
-
Hospital List: Insurers have tiered lists of eligible hospitals. A policy with a nationwide list including premium London hospitals will cost more than one with a more restricted local list.
-
Underwriting Type: This determines how the insurer assesses your pre-existing medical conditions.
- Moratorium (MORI): You don't declare your medical history upfront. The insurer automatically excludes any condition you've had symptoms, advice, or treatment for in the 5 years before the policy started. If you then go 2 continuous years on the policy without any issues relating to that condition, it may become eligible for cover.
- Full Medical Underwriting (FMU): You complete a detailed health questionnaire. The insurer assesses your history and issues a policy with a clear list of permanent exclusions. It provides certainty from day one.
As expert PMI brokers, WeCovr can instantly model how changing any of these factors will affect your premium, finding the sweet spot between comprehensive cover and an affordable price.
Real-Life Scenarios: When Does Joint Cover Make Sense?
Theory is one thing, but practical examples show how these choices play out. Let's look at three common scenarios.
Scenario 1: The Young, Healthy Couple
- Who: Ben and Chloe, both 32, non-smokers, living in Manchester.
- Health: Both are in excellent health with no pre-existing conditions. They want a mid-range policy with some out-patient cover for peace of mind.
- Analysis: For Ben and Chloe, a joint policy is likely the best option. Their risk profiles are identical, so there's no pricing disadvantage. They will benefit from the 5% multi-person discount and the simplicity of a single policy. The shared No Claims Discount is a risk, but as they are young and healthy, it's a risk they may be willing to take for the upfront saving and convenience.
Scenario 2: The Age-Gap Couple
- Who: David, 58, and Sarah, 43, living in Surrey.
- Health: Sarah is very healthy. David has well-managed high blood pressure (a chronic condition not covered by PMI) and had knee surgery 4 years ago for a sports injury.
- Analysis: This is a classic case where two separate policies are almost certainly better.
- David's age (58) will significantly increase any premium.
- His pre-existing knee condition will be excluded under either underwriting type (it falls within the 5-year moratorium period).
- Lumping them together on a joint policy means Sarah's premium is artificially inflated by David's higher age and health risk.
- By taking out separate policies, Sarah can get a much cheaper policy based on her own excellent health and age. David can get a policy tailored to him. The total cost of two separate plans will likely be less than one joint plan.
Scenario 3: The Different Needs Couple
- Who: Mark, 45, and Emily, 42, living in Bristol.
- Health: Both are generally healthy.
- Needs: Mark has a high-stress job and wants a comprehensive policy with full mental health cover and unlimited therapies. Emily is self-employed and budget-conscious; she only wants basic in-patient cover to protect against major medical events and long NHS waits.
- Analysis: They have two good options, and a broker comparison is essential.
- A flexible joint policy: Insurers like Bupa and Vitality are great at allowing different cover levels on one policy. Mark could add his comprehensive options while Emily keeps a basic plan. This maintains administrative simplicity.
- Two separate policies: This may offer even better value. Mark could choose an insurer that specialises in comprehensive mental health cover, while Emily could find a budget-friendly plan from another provider. A broker like WeCovr can compare the "blended" joint policy against the "best-of-both-worlds" separate policies to find the most cost-effective solution.
The Critical Role of the No Claims Discount (NCD) in Couples PMI
This is a concept borrowed from car insurance, but it works slightly differently with PMI and is a crucial factor in the joint vs. separate debate.
A No Claims Discount rewards you for not using your policy. For every year you don't claim, you move up a level on the insurer's NCD scale, earning a larger discount on your renewal premium (often up to 60-75%).
- On a Joint Policy: The NCD is shared. If either you or your partner makes a claim, the NCD for the entire policy is typically reduced. This means at renewal, the premium will increase not just because of the claim, but because your discount has shrunk. This "double-hit" can lead to surprisingly large price hikes.
- On Separate Policies: The NCD is individual. If your partner claims, it has zero impact on your policy. Your NCD is protected, and your renewal premium will only be affected by age-related increases and general medical inflation, not their claim.
Adviser's Take: The NCD risk is the single most compelling financial argument for taking out two separate policies. While you might save 5% upfront with a joint policy, a single claim can wipe out that saving for many years to come.
Understanding Underwriting for Couples
When you apply for PMI, the insurer "underwrites" your policy to decide what they will and will not cover based on your medical history.
| Underwriting Type | How It Works | Best For... |
|---|---|---|
| Moratorium (MORI) | No medical questions upfront. Automatically excludes conditions you've had in the last 5 years. After 2 claim-free years on the policy, those past conditions may become eligible for cover. | Young, healthy couples with no significant medical history. It's fast and simple. |
| Full Medical Underwriting (FMU) | You complete a detailed health questionnaire. The insurer assesses your history and gives you a clear list of what is and isn't covered from day one. | Couples where one or both partners have a pre-existing condition or a complex medical history. It provides absolute clarity. |
The WeCovr Golden Rule: If you have any past health concerns, FMU is almost always the better choice. It avoids the uncertainty of a moratorium policy, where you might only discover something isn't covered when you try to make a claim. Our advisers can guide you through the FMU process to ensure full and accurate disclosure.
Major UK Private Health Insurance Providers for Couples
The UK market is served by several excellent insurers, each with different strengths. As an independent broker, we are not tied to any single one, allowing us to find the perfect fit for you.
- Bupa: A household name with an extensive network and highly flexible policies that are well-suited to customising cover on joint plans.
- AXA Health: A global insurance giant with a strong UK presence, offering robust cover options and excellent digital health services.
- Vitality: Unique in its focus on wellness. Couples can earn significant premium discounts and rewards by staying active and engaging with the Vitality Programme.
- Aviva: One of the UK's largest insurers, providing a solid, reliable core PMI product that is often very competitively priced.
- WPA: A not-for-profit provider with a strong customer service reputation, offering a range of specialist policies.
Our job at WeCovr is to analyse your specific needs and compare quotes from these providers and others to determine whether a joint or separate policy structure offers you the ultimate combination of cover and value.
WeCovr's Added Value for Couples
Choosing the right health insurance structure can save you thousands of pounds over the lifetime of your policy. This isn't a decision to be taken lightly, and that's where our expertise becomes invaluable.
At WeCovr, we provide a completely free, no-obligation service to:
- Analyse your unique situation: We listen to your needs, health history, and budget.
- Compare the market: We run quotes for both joint and separate policies across all leading UK insurers.
- Provide expert advice: We'll show you the true cost difference and explain the long-term pros and cons of each option, empowering you to make the best choice.
As a WeCovr client, you also get exclusive benefits:
- Complimentary access to CalorieHero: Our powerful AI-driven calorie and nutrition tracking app to support your health goals.
- Multi-policy discounts: When you take out a PMI policy with us, you can get discounts on other vital cover like life insurance or income protection.
Our high customer satisfaction ratings are built on providing clear, honest, and expert advice that puts our clients' needs first.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What happens to our joint health insurance if we separate?
Can we have different levels of cover on a joint policy?
Does private health insurance cover pregnancy and childbirth?
Is the cost of private health insurance tax-deductible for individuals?
Your Next Step
The decision between a joint policy and two separate ones is the most important financial choice you'll make when buying couples health insurance. While a joint plan offers a small discount and simplicity, separate policies provide long-term financial protection for your No Claims Discount and greater flexibility.
The only way to know for sure which is right for you is to compare them.
Contact a WeCovr adviser today for a free, impartial market comparison. We’ll do the hard work for you, presenting clear options so you can secure the best possible protection for you and your partner.
