Self-Pay vs PMI Which is Cheaper for Surgery
As an FCA-authorised broker that has helped arrange over 800,000 policies, WeCovr understands the UK private medical insurance market. When facing surgery, deciding between paying yourself or using a policy is a major financial question. This guide breaks down the costs to help you choose wisely.
Comparing out-of-pocket surgery costs with PMI premiums
In the UK, when you need surgery and want to bypass NHS waiting lists, you have two primary options: paying for the procedure directly out-of-pocket (known as 'self-pay' or 'self-funding') or using a private medical insurance (PMI) policy.
The choice isn't always straightforward. A one-off payment for a minor procedure might seem cheaper than years of monthly insurance premiums. However, the true value of PMI often lies in its protection against unforeseen, complex, and expensive health issues. This guide will dissect the costs, benefits, and potential pitfalls of each path, helping you determine which is the most financially sound choice for your health and your wallet.
Understanding Self-Pay Surgery Costs in the UK
Self-pay is exactly what it sounds like: you fund the entire cost of your private medical treatment yourself. You choose the hospital and the consultant, agree on a price, and pay them directly. This is a popular option for those who need a specific, one-off procedure and have the savings to cover it.
What are the typical costs for private surgery?
Private surgery costs can vary significantly based on the hospital's location, the consultant's reputation, and the complexity of the procedure. To give you a realistic picture, here are some estimated costs for common surgeries in the UK for 2025.
| Surgery Type | Estimated Self-Pay Cost Range | Key Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Cataract Surgery (per eye) | £2,500 – £4,500 | Price depends on the type of lens implant used. |
| Hip Replacement | £12,000 – £17,000 | Includes consultant fees, hospital stay, and initial physio. |
| Knee Replacement | £13,000 – £18,000 | Similar to hip replacement, with variations for partial vs. total. |
| Hernia Repair (Inguinal) | £3,000 – £5,000 | Usually a day-case procedure, which keeps costs lower. |
| Gallbladder Removal | £6,000 – £8,500 | Typically involves a short hospital stay. |
| ACL Reconstruction (Knee) | £7,000 – £10,000 | A more complex procedure often requiring specialist sports surgeons. |
| Endoscopy / Gastroscopy | £1,500 – £2,500 | Diagnostic procedure, price can increase if a biopsy is taken. |
Source: Figures are estimates based on 2024/2025 market analysis from private hospital groups and the Private Healthcare Information Network (PHIN). Prices are illustrative and can change.
What's Included in a Self-Pay 'Package Price'?
Most private hospitals offer a 'package price' for common procedures. This is designed to give you clarity and peace of mind. A typical package usually includes:
- The initial consultation with the specialist
- The surgery itself, including the surgeon's and anaesthetist's fees
- Hospital accommodation, nursing care, and meals
- Standard diagnostic tests and scans required during your stay
- One follow-up consultation after your surgery
Crucially, you must check what is NOT included. This can often be the source of unexpected bills. Exclusions might include:
- Initial diagnostic tests before the procedure is confirmed (e.g., the first MRI scan)
- Treatment for unrelated conditions discovered during your stay
- The cost of treating any unforeseen complications that require extra time in theatre or a longer hospital stay
- Extended physiotherapy or rehabilitation beyond the initial package terms
Pros and Cons of Paying for Surgery Yourself
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| No Ongoing Commitment: You pay once for a specific service. | High Upfront Cost: Requires significant available savings. |
| Total Control: You choose the exact hospital and consultant. | Financial Risk: Complications can lead to spiralling, uncapped costs. |
| Speed: Can be extremely fast for a planned procedure. | Limited Scope: Only covers the one procedure you pay for. |
| No Medical Underwriting: Your past health doesn't affect the price. | Doesn't Cover Future Needs: Another health issue means another large bill. |
Understanding Private Medical Insurance (PMI) Premiums
Private medical insurance is a policy you pay for, usually monthly or annually, that covers the costs of eligible private treatment for acute conditions. Think of it like car or home insurance, but for your health. Instead of facing a huge bill for surgery, your insurer pays the hospital and specialists directly, up to the limits of your policy.
The Most Important Rule: Acute vs. Chronic Conditions
This is the single most critical concept to understand about private medical insurance in the UK:
- PMI covers ACUTE conditions. An acute condition is a disease, illness, or injury that is likely to respond quickly to treatment and lead to a full recovery (e.g., a cataract, a hernia, a broken bone).
- PMI does NOT cover CHRONIC conditions. A chronic condition is one that continues indefinitely and has no known cure. It can only be managed, not fixed (e.g., diabetes, asthma, high blood pressure).
- PMI does NOT cover PRE-EXISTING conditions. This means any illness or symptom you had before you took out the policy will not be covered, usually for the first two years.
PMI is designed to get you back to your normal state of health after a new, treatable condition arises.
What Determines Your PMI Premium?
Insurers calculate your premium based on risk. The key factors are:
- Age: The older you are, the higher the statistical likelihood of needing treatment, so premiums increase.
- Location: Treatment costs more in central London and other major cities, so living there can increase your premium.
- Level of Cover: A comprehensive policy with full cancer care and a wide choice of hospitals will cost more than a basic plan.
- Excess: This is a fixed amount you agree to pay towards any claim (e.g., £250). A higher excess will lower your monthly premium.
- Hospital List: Policies offer different tiers of hospitals. A list that includes only local private hospitals will be cheaper than one that provides access to premium central London facilities.
- Lifestyle: Being a smoker will significantly increase your premium.
Example PMI Premiums (Illustrative)
To give you a clearer idea, here are some sample monthly premiums. These are for illustrative purposes only and are not a formal quote.
| Profile | Basic Cover (High Excess, Core Hospitals) | Comprehensive Cover (Low Excess, Full Hospital List, Therapies) |
|---|---|---|
| 30-year-old, non-smoker | £35 – £50 per month | £60 – £85 per month |
| 45-year-old, non-smoker | £55 – £75 per month | £90 – £130 per month |
| Couple, both aged 55 | £140 – £190 per month | £220 – £300+ per month |
Note: These are industry estimates for 2025. An expert PMI broker like WeCovr can provide you with precise quotes from across the market tailored to your needs.
Pros and Cons of Private Medical Insurance
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Budgetable Costs: Predictable monthly payments instead of a huge one-off bill. | Ongoing Cost: You pay the premium whether you claim or not. |
| Peace of Mind: Protects you against the cost of major, unexpected illnesses. | Exclusions Apply: Doesn't cover chronic or pre-existing conditions. |
| Comprehensive Cover: Can cover diagnostics, surgery, cancer care, and therapies. | Premiums Can Rise: Premiums typically increase with age and after claims. |
| Added Benefits: Many policies include virtual GP access and mental health support. | Policy Limits: Cover is subject to the terms and annual limits of your plan. |
The Breakeven Point: When Does PMI Become More Cost-Effective?
This is the central question. To answer it, we need to compare the cumulative cost of PMI premiums against the potential one-off costs of self-funded surgery.
Let's look at a few common scenarios. We'll use a hypothetical 45-year-old person, "Alex," whose comprehensive PMI policy costs £100 per month (£1,200 per year).
Scenario 1: One Major Planned Surgery
Alex needs a hip replacement, which costs £14,000 to self-fund.
- Self-Pay Cost: £14,000
- PMI Cost: Alex has been paying for their policy for 8 years. Total premiums paid = £1,200 x 8 = £9,600.
Verdict: In this case, PMI is £4,400 cheaper. Alex also had peace of mind for 8 years, knowing they were covered for a whole range of other potential issues during that time.
Scenario 2: A Series of Smaller Issues
Over a 10-year period, Alex remains relatively healthy but needs a few common procedures.
- Year 2: Hernia repair. Self-pay cost: £3,500.
- Year 6: Knee arthroscopy (keyhole surgery). Self-pay cost: £4,000.
- Year 9: Cataract surgery in one eye. Self-pay cost: £2,800.
Let's compare the totals:
- Total Self-Pay Cost: £3,500 + £4,000 + £2,800 = £10,300
- Total PMI Premiums over 10 years: £1,200 x 10 = £12,000 (assuming the premium stays the same for simplicity).
Verdict: In this specific scenario, self-pay appears slightly cheaper. However, this calculation makes a dangerous assumption: that Alex knew exactly what health issues they would face. The PMI cost provided 10 years of protection against any eligible acute condition, including catastrophic ones like cancer or heart surgery, which would have dwarf these costs.
Scenario 3: The Unexpected and Expensive Diagnosis
In year 5 of their policy, Alex is diagnosed with bowel cancer. Treatment requires major surgery, chemotherapy, and specialist drugs.
- Self-Pay Cost: The cost of private cancer treatment can easily exceed £50,000 - £70,000 in the first year alone, and some advanced drugs are not routinely available on the NHS. This cost would be financially devastating for most families.
- PMI Cost: Alex's comprehensive PMI policy covers the full cost of their treatment, including diagnostics, surgery, and access to breakthrough cancer drugs. Their total outlay is their accumulated premiums (£1,200 x 5 = £6,000) plus any policy excess (e.g., £250).
Verdict: This is where private medical insurance proves its ultimate worth. It acts as a financial shield against the catastrophic costs of serious illness, which are impossible to plan for. The breakeven point is immediate and overwhelming.
Comparison Summary
| Aspect | Self-Pay | Private Medical Insurance (PMI) |
|---|---|---|
| Ideal Use Case | A single, planned, affordable procedure. | Long-term peace of mind and protection against all future acute conditions. |
| Financial Model | High, one-off payment. | Low, regular monthly/annual payment. |
| Risk Profile | High risk. You bear the full cost of complications. | Low risk. The insurer bears the financial risk. |
| Best For... | Those with large savings and a specific, non-urgent need. | Those wanting to budget for healthcare and protect against major illness. |
The 'Hidden' Costs and Benefits to Consider
The comparison isn't just about surgery costs vs. premiums. Both options come with other financial and lifestyle factors.
The True Cost of Self-Pay
The initial quote for self-pay surgery might not be the final bill. Be aware of:
- Pre-Surgical Diagnostics: The MRI, CT, or X-ray needed to confirm your diagnosis is often billed separately before you get a package price. This can be £300 - £800.
- Consultant Hopping: You might pay for initial consultations with two or three different specialists (£200-£300 each) before choosing one.
- The Cost of Complications: If you suffer a post-operative infection or need revision surgery, the 'package price' may not cover it. This is the biggest financial risk of self-pay.
- Rehabilitation: A standard package might include one or two physiotherapy sessions. If you need ten, you'll pay for the extra eight yourself.
The Added Value of Private Medical Insurance
Modern PMI policies are much more than just a ticket to surgery. The value-added benefits often make the monthly premium feel more worthwhile, even in years when you don't claim.
- Digital GP Services: Most major insurers offer 24/7 access to a private GP via phone or video call, often with same-day appointments. This benefit alone can be worth hundreds of pounds a year for a family.
- Mental Health Support: Policies increasingly include access to counselling or therapy sessions, providing fast support for issues like stress, anxiety, and depression without a long wait.
- Wellness Programmes: Insurers actively encourage healthy living. They may offer discounts on gym memberships, fitness trackers, and health screenings.
- Expert Second Opinions: If you receive a serious diagnosis, your insurer can arrange for a world-leading expert to review your case and treatment plan.
- WeCovr Client Perks: When you arrange your policy through a dedicated broker like WeCovr, you can access exclusive benefits. We provide our PMI and Life insurance clients with complimentary access to our AI-powered diet and calorie tracking app, CalorieHero, to support their health goals. Furthermore, our clients often receive discounts on other types of cover they arrange with us.
Making the Right Choice for You
So, self-pay or PMI? The right answer depends entirely on your personal and financial situation. Ask yourself these questions:
- What is my financial situation? Do I have £15,000+ in accessible savings that I'm comfortable spending on a single medical event, knowing I might need it again for something else? Or would a predictable monthly cost of £70 be more manageable?
- What is my risk appetite? Am I comfortable with the small but significant risk that complications could double my surgery bill? Or do I want the certainty that an insurer will handle any unexpected costs?
- What is my health outlook? Am I dealing with a one-off issue (like a worn-out joint), or do I want broader protection for my family against whatever might happen in the future?
- How much do I value convenience? Would I use a 24/7 digital GP service or mental health support? The added benefits of PMI can often tip the balance.
- Self-pay might be right for you if: You need a single, relatively low-cost procedure, your condition is pre-existing (and thus excluded from new PMI), and you have substantial savings you are prepared to use.
- PMI is likely a better choice if: You want long-term peace of mind, you don't have large liquid savings, you want to protect your family, you value the additional wellness and digital health benefits, and you want to ensure you're covered for serious illnesses like cancer.
How an Expert PMI Broker Can Help
Navigating the world of private medical insurance can be complex. The market is filled with different providers, policy types, and confusing jargon. This is where an independent broker like WeCovr is invaluable.
- We do the shopping for you: We compare policies from all the leading UK insurers to find the one that best fits your needs and budget.
- We provide impartial advice: As an FCA-authorised broker, our duty is to you, not the insurance company. We'll explain the pros and cons of each policy in plain English.
- We save you money: We can often find deals and policy combinations that aren't available to the public directly.
- It costs you nothing: Our service is paid for by the insurer, so you get expert advice and support at no extra cost.
Does private medical insurance in the UK cover pre-existing conditions?
Will my PMI premium go up if I claim for surgery?
What is an 'excess' on a health insurance policy?
Is it cheaper to get private medical insurance when I'm younger?
Ready to explore your options?
Deciding between self-pay and PMI is a significant choice. For comprehensive protection and long-term peace of mind, private medical insurance is often the most financially prudent path.
Contact WeCovr today for a free, no-obligation quote. Our expert advisors will compare the UK's leading insurers to find the perfect cover for your needs and budget.
Why private medical insurance and how does it work?
What is Private Medical Insurance?
Private medical insurance (PMI) is a type of health insurance that provides access to private healthcare services in the UK. It covers the cost of private medical treatment, allowing you to bypass NHS waiting lists and receive faster, more convenient care.How does it work?
Private medical insurance works by paying for your private healthcare costs. When you need treatment, you can choose to go private and your insurance will cover the costs, subject to your policy terms and conditions. This can include:• Private consultations with specialists
• Private hospital treatment and surgery
• Diagnostic tests and scans
• Physiotherapy and rehabilitation
• Mental health treatment
Your premium depends on factors like your age, health, occupation, and the level of cover you choose. Most policies offer different levels of cover, from basic to comprehensive, allowing you to tailor the policy to your needs and budget.
Questions to ask yourself regarding private medical insurance
Just ask yourself:👉 Are you concerned about NHS waiting times for treatment?
👉 Would you prefer to choose your own consultant and hospital?
👉 Do you want faster access to diagnostic tests and scans?
👉 Would you like private hospital accommodation and better food?
👉 Do you want to avoid the stress of NHS waiting lists?
Many people don't realise that private medical insurance is more affordable than they think, especially when you consider the value of faster treatment and better facilities. A great insurance policy can provide peace of mind and ensure you receive the care you need when you need it.
Benefits offered by private medical insurance
Private medical insurance provides numerous benefits that can significantly improve your healthcare experience and outcomes:Faster Access to Treatment
One of the biggest advantages is avoiding NHS waiting lists. While the NHS provides excellent care, waiting times can be lengthy. With private medical insurance, you can often receive treatment within days or weeks rather than months.
Choice of Consultant and Hospital
You can choose your preferred consultant and hospital, giving you more control over your healthcare journey. This is particularly important for complex treatments where you want a specific specialist.
Better Facilities and Accommodation
Private hospitals typically offer superior facilities, including private rooms, better food, and more comfortable surroundings. This can make your recovery more pleasant and potentially faster.
Advanced Treatments
Private medical insurance often covers treatments and medications not available on the NHS, giving you access to the latest medical advances and technologies.
Mental Health Support
Many policies include comprehensive mental health coverage, providing faster access to therapy and psychiatric care when needed.
Tax Benefits for Business Owners
If you're self-employed or a business owner, private medical insurance premiums can be tax-deductible, making it a cost-effective way to protect your health and your business.
Peace of Mind
Knowing you have access to private healthcare when you need it provides invaluable peace of mind, especially for those with ongoing health conditions or concerns about NHS capacity.
Private medical insurance is particularly valuable for those who want to take control of their healthcare journey and ensure they receive the best possible treatment when they need it most.
Important Fact!
We can look at a more suitable option mid-term!
Why is it important to get private medical insurance early?
👉 Many people are very thankful that they had their private medical insurance cover in place before running into some serious health issues. Private medical insurance is as important as life insurance for protecting your family's finances.👉 We insure our cars, houses, and even our phones! Yet our health is the most precious thing we have.
Easily one of the most important insurance purchases an individual or family can make in their lifetime, the decision to buy private medical insurance can be made much simpler with the help of FCA-authorised advisers. They are the specialists who do the searching and analysis helping people choose between various types of private medical insurance policies available in the market, including different levels of cover and policy types most suitable to the client's individual circumstances.
It certainly won't do any harm if you speak with one of our experienced insurance experts who are passionate about advising people on financial matters related to private medical insurance and are keen to provide you with a free consultation.
You can discuss with them in detail what affordable private medical insurance plan for the necessary peace of mind they would recommend! WeCovr works with some of the best advisers in the market.
By tapping the button below, you can book a free call with them in less than 30 seconds right now:
Our Group Is Proud To Have Issued 800,000+ Policies!
We've established collaboration agreements with leading insurance groups to create tailored coverage
How It Works
1. Complete a brief form
2. Our experts analyse your information and find you best quotes
3. Enjoy your protection!
Any questions?
Learn more
Who Are WeCovr?
WeCovr is an insurance specialist for people valuing their peace of mind and a great service.👍 WeCovr will help you get your private medical insurance, life insurance, critical illness insurance and others in no time thanks to our wonderful super-friendly experts ready to assist you every step of the way.
Just a quick and simple form and an easy conversation with one of our experts and your valuable insurance policy is in place for that needed peace of mind!