As an FCA-authorised expert with over 800,000 policies arranged, WeCovr provides insight into the UK private medical insurance market. This guide dissects the costs of major hospital groups, helping you understand how your choice of facility directly impacts your insurance premiums and the value you receive.
WeCovr reviews Spire, Nuffield, HCA, and Circle costs to see who is most expensive
Choosing a private medical insurance (PMI) policy in the UK involves more than just picking an insurer; it's also about deciding where you'll receive your treatment. The hospital you choose can have the single biggest impact on the cost of your policy and the quality of your care.
The UK's private healthcare landscape is dominated by a few large hospital groups. For this review, we are focusing on the 'big four': Spire Healthcare, Nuffield Health, HCA Healthcare UK, and Circle Health Group. Understanding the differences in their pricing, specialisms, and geographic locations is crucial for making an informed decision about your health cover.
At WeCovr, we believe in empowering you with clear, expert information. Let's delve into the data to see who charges more and what you get for your money.
Why Your Choice of Hospital Matters for Your PMI Premiums
When you buy private health cover, you're not just paying for access to a consultant; you're paying for the entire treatment pathway. This includes the hospital's operating theatres, nursing staff, diagnostic equipment (like MRI and CT scanners), and your overnight stay.
Insurers are acutely aware that some hospitals cost significantly more than others. To manage their costs—and yours—they create 'hospital lists' or 'tiers'.
- Higher Cost Hospitals = Higher Premiums: If you want a policy that includes access to the most expensive hospitals, typically those in Central London with world-renowned specialists and state-of-the-art technology, your premium will be higher.
- Lower Cost Hospitals = Lower Premiums: If you are happy with a more restricted list of hospitals, perhaps excluding those in major city centres, you can significantly reduce your monthly payments.
Think of it like car insurance. Insuring a high-performance sports car kept in a city centre will always cost more than insuring a family hatchback in a quiet village. The principle is the same: higher risk or cost to the insurer translates to a higher premium for you.
Understanding Hospital Lists and Tiers in Private Health Insurance
Insurers don't just have one master list of hospitals. They carefully categorise them into bands or tiers to offer you different levels of cover at different price points. While the names vary between insurers (e.g., 'Key', 'Extended', 'Premium'), they generally fall into these categories:
- Basic or Local Lists: These offer the lowest premiums. They typically include a curated selection of private hospitals from groups like Spire and Nuffield but may exclude facilities in major metropolitan hubs, especially London. This can be a great value option if you live outside a major city and are happy with local treatment.
- Standard or National Lists: This is the most common option. It provides access to a wide range of hospitals across the UK, including most facilities from Spire, Nuffield, and Circle Health Group. It offers a good balance between choice and cost.
- Comprehensive or Premium Lists: This is the top-tier option, offering unrestricted access to almost any private hospital in the UK. Crucially, this tier includes the high-cost hospitals in Central London, such as those run by HCA Healthcare UK. This option carries the highest premium.
A specialist PMI broker like WeCovr can help you navigate these lists to find a policy that includes the hospitals you'd want to use without making you overpay for facilities you'll never visit.
Introducing the 'Big Four': A Profile of Spire, Nuffield, HCA, and Circle
These four groups represent the vast majority of private hospital beds in the United Kingdom. Each has a distinct identity and market position.
| Feature | Spire Healthcare | Nuffield Health | HCA Healthcare UK | Circle Health Group |
|---|
| Number of Hospitals | Around 40 | 37 | 7 (plus clinics) | Around 50 |
| Primary Focus | Broad UK coverage, wide range of procedures | Integrated health & wellness (hospitals, gyms, clinics) | Complex care, Central London, international patients | Modern facilities, patient experience, national network |
| Ownership Model | Publicly listed company (PLC) | Not-for-profit charitable trust | US-owned private company | Independent, previously acquired BMI Healthcare |
| Typical Price Point | Mid to High | Mid-range | Premium / Very High | Mid to High |
| Geographic Spread | Excellent national coverage | Strong national coverage | Heavily London-centric | Excellent national coverage |
The Cost Breakdown: Comparing Spire, Nuffield, HCA, and Circle
Now for the central question: who is the most expensive? To answer this, we need to look at the 'self-pay' or 'package' prices for common procedures. While your insurer negotiates rates, these guide prices are a strong indicator of the underlying cost structure.
A crucial note on pricing: The costs below are illustrative estimates for 2025 and are for comparison purposes only. Actual prices vary based on the specific consultant, the complexity of your case, the exact hospital location, and the type of implant or prosthesis used.
Illustrative Costs for Common Private Procedures (2025)
| Procedure | Nuffield Health (Mid-Range) | Spire Healthcare (Mid-High) | Circle Health (Mid-High) | HCA Healthcare (Premium) |
|---|
| MRI Scan (1 part) | £400 - £600 | £450 - £700 | £450 - £750 | £800 - £1,200+ |
| Cataract Surgery (1 eye) | £2,500 - £3,200 | £2,600 - £3,500 | £2,700 - £3,600 | £3,800 - £5,000+ |
| Knee Arthroscopy | £3,800 - £4,800 | £4,000 - £5,200 | £4,200 - £5,500 | £6,000 - £8,000+ |
| Hernia Repair (Inguinal) | £3,000 - £4,000 | £3,200 - £4,400 | £3,300 - £4,500 | £4,800 - £6,500+ |
| Hip Replacement | £12,500 - £15,000 | £13,000 - £16,000 | £13,500 - £16,500 | £18,000 - £25,000+ |
| Knee Replacement | £13,000 - £15,500 | £13,500 - £16,500 | £14,000 - £17,000 | £19,000 - £26,000+ |
Analysis:
As the table clearly shows, HCA Healthcare UK is consistently the most expensive hospital group, often by a significant margin. Their costs reflect their Central London locations, investment in cutting-edge robotic surgery and cancer care, and their ability to attract world-leading consultants.
Nuffield Health often appears as the most competitively priced, which may be influenced by its not-for-profit charitable status. Spire and Circle Health Group are closely matched, occupying the middle-to-high ground and forming the backbone of most standard private medical insurance UK hospital lists.
A Closer Look at HCA Healthcare UK: The Premium Choice
HCA is synonymous with top-tier private medical care in London. Their facilities, including The Harley Street Clinic, The Lister Hospital, and London Bridge Hospital, are where you go for highly complex procedures.
- Strengths: Unrivalled access to leading specialists, particularly in oncology (cancer), cardiology (heart), and neurosciences. They have some of the most advanced diagnostic and treatment technology in Europe.
- Why so expensive?
- Location: Prime Central London real estate carries immense overheads.
- Technology: Constant investment in the latest medical equipment is costly.
- Staffing: Attracting and retaining the very best clinical and nursing staff demands premium salaries.
- Complexity: They handle some of the most difficult and resource-intensive medical cases, often for international patients.
- Who needs an HCA-inclusive policy? If you live or work in London and want no-compromise access to the absolute best specialists and facilities for serious conditions, then including HCA on your hospital list is essential.
A Closer Look at Spire Healthcare: The UK's Largest Network
Spire Healthcare is one of the UK's largest private hospital providers by revenue and reach. With around 40 hospitals and 8 clinics across England, Wales, and Scotland, they are a cornerstone of the UK PMI market.
- Strengths: Excellent geographic coverage means most people are within a reasonable drive of a Spire hospital. They offer a comprehensive range of services, from routine diagnostics to complex surgery. They are a trusted partner for the NHS, often helping to reduce waiting lists.
- Pricing Position: Spire sits in the mid-to-high price bracket. They are more expensive than many Nuffield hospitals but more affordable than HCA. They represent the "default" high-quality option for many insurers.
- Who is Spire good for? Anyone looking for a reliable, high-quality national network. A policy that includes Spire gives you fantastic choice and accessibility almost anywhere in the country.
A Closer Look at Nuffield Health: The Wellness-Focused Charity
Nuffield Health is unique because it is a registered charity, not a shareholder-owned company. This means all profits are reinvested back into the organisation's mission of "building a healthier nation."
- Strengths: Their integrated model connects hospitals with fitness and wellbeing centres (gyms) and health assessment clinics. This allows for a focus on preventative health and rehabilitation. As a charity, their ethos is centred on patient outcomes rather than profit. They also offer a unique 'Recovery Plus' programme for certain procedures, providing post-op physiotherapy at their gyms.
- Pricing Position: Generally in the mid-range. Their not-for-profit status can lead to more competitive pricing on certain procedures, making them an excellent value proposition.
- Who is Nuffield good for? Patients who appreciate a holistic approach to health that extends beyond the operating theatre. Their focus on rehabilitation and prevention is a significant benefit.
A Closer Look at Circle Health Group: The Modern Challenger
Circle Health Group became one of the UK's largest hospital operators after acquiring BMI Healthcare. They have a strong reputation for modern, well-designed facilities and a focus on the patient experience, often described as more like a hotel than a hospital.
- Strengths: State-of-the-art hospitals with a strong emphasis on patient comfort and technology. Their national network is now vast, rivalling Spire's. They have invested heavily in new facilities and technology, including pioneering rehabilitation centres.
- Pricing Position: Similar to Spire, they occupy the mid-to-high price bracket. They compete on service, technology, and patient environment.
- Who is Circle good for? Patients who value a modern, comfortable environment and a seamless patient journey. Their national scale makes them a core part of almost all standard PMI policies.
How Insurers' Hospital Lists Affect Your Monthly Premium
To see how this all plays out in your bank account, let's look at some illustrative examples. The premiums below are for a 45-year-old non-smoker seeking comprehensive cover with a £250 excess.
| Hospital List Tier | Included Hospital Groups | Illustrative Monthly Premium | Who It's For |
|---|
| Tier 1: Local / Basic | Selected Nuffield, Circle, Spire (No Central London) | £75 | Someone living outside a major city, happy with local high-quality care, and seeking maximum value. |
| Tier 2: Standard / National | Full Nuffield, Circle, Spire networks (No Central London) | £95 | The majority of UK customers. Offers extensive choice and national coverage at a competitive price. |
| Tier 3: Comprehensive / Premium | All hospitals, including HCA in Central London | £140 | London-based professionals or those who want guaranteed access to the UK's most prestigious hospitals. |
As you can see, simply adding the premium Central London hospitals (primarily HCA) can increase a premium by nearly 50%. This is why it's so important to get expert advice. If you don't live near London, paying for a Tier 3 list is often poor value. The team at WeCovr can run a detailed market comparison to ensure you're only paying for the cover you actually need.
This is one of the most important principles of private health cover in the UK. It's vital to understand what PMI is designed for.
Private medical insurance is designed to cover acute conditions that arise after you take out your policy.
- An acute condition is a disease, illness, or injury that is likely to respond quickly to treatment and lead to a full recovery. Examples include a hernia, cataracts, or a joint injury requiring replacement.
- A pre-existing condition is any illness or injury you had symptoms of, or received advice or treatment for, in the years before your policy began (typically the last 5 years).
- A chronic condition is an illness that cannot be cured and needs long-term management, such as diabetes, asthma, or high blood pressure.
Standard UK PMI policies do not cover the treatment of pre-existing or chronic conditions. They are designed for unexpected, short-term health issues, providing a route to faster diagnosis and treatment outside of the NHS.
Boosting Your Wellbeing: Small Steps for a Healthier Life
While insurance is there for when things go wrong, the best strategy is to stay healthy. Investing in your wellbeing can reduce your long-term health risks. Here are some simple, effective tips:
- Nourish Your Body: Focus on a balanced diet rich in whole foods. Aim for five portions of fruit and vegetables a day, lean proteins, and whole grains. Reduce your intake of processed foods, sugar, and saturated fats. Using an app can help track your intake. As a WeCovr customer, you get complimentary access to our AI-powered calorie and nutrition tracker, CalorieHero.
- Move Every Day: The NHS recommends at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity activity (like brisk walking or cycling) or 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity (like running or swimming) a week. Find an activity you enjoy to make it a sustainable habit.
- Prioritise Sleep: Aim for 7-9 hours of quality sleep per night. Create a relaxing bedtime routine, avoid screens before bed, and ensure your bedroom is dark, quiet, and cool. Good sleep is essential for mental and physical recovery.
- Manage Stress: Chronic stress can negatively impact your health. Practice mindfulness, meditation, or simple breathing exercises. Spending time in nature and connecting with loved ones are also powerful stress relievers.
How WeCovr Helps You Find the Right Balance of Cost and Cover
Navigating the complexities of hospital lists, insurer jargon, and policy exclusions can be daunting. This is where an expert, independent PMI broker proves invaluable.
At WeCovr, we don't just sell you a policy; we provide a service.
- We Listen: We take the time to understand your needs, your budget, and what's important to you in a healthcare provider.
- We Compare: We use our expertise and technology to analyse policies from across the market, comparing not just price but also the crucial details of their hospital lists and benefit limits. We enjoy high customer satisfaction ratings on major review websites because we put our clients first.
- We Advise: We explain your options in plain English, highlighting the pros and cons of each, so you can make a confident choice.
- We Add Value: When you take out a private medical or life insurance policy with us, you get complimentary access to our CalorieHero app. We also offer discounts on other types of insurance, helping you protect your family and finances more affordably.
Our service is provided at no cost to you. We receive a commission from the insurer you choose, but our advice remains completely impartial and focused on your best interests.
Is the most expensive hospital always the best?
Not necessarily. "Best" is subjective and depends on your needs. The most expensive hospitals, like those in the HCA group, are exceptional for complex and specialist care, particularly in London. However, for more routine procedures like a hip replacement or cataract surgery, a hospital from Nuffield Health or Spire may offer equally excellent clinical outcomes in a more convenient location and at a lower cost to your insurer, keeping premiums down. The 'best' hospital is one with a strong track record for your specific procedure.
Can I change my hospital list after my policy has started?
Yes, you can typically change your hospital list, but usually only at your policy's annual renewal date. You can choose to upgrade to a more comprehensive list (which will increase your premium) or downgrade to a more restricted list to save money. You cannot, however, change your hospital list mid-term simply because you need to make a claim at a hospital not on your current list. This is why it's so important to choose the right list from the start with help from a PMI broker.
Does private medical insurance UK cover the consultant's fees as well as the hospital costs?
Yes, a core benefit of private medical insurance is that it covers the costs of the specialist consultant and the anaesthetist as well as the hospital's charges. However, most insurers have fee guidelines and will only cover fees up to a certain level. The vast majority of consultants charge within these guidelines, but it's always wise to check with your insurer before beginning treatment to ensure your chosen consultant's fees will be covered in full.
Ready to find the perfect balance of cost, choice, and quality for your health cover?
Get your free, no-obligation quote from a WeCovr expert today and see how much you could save.